Ikigai LawIkigai LawIkigai LawIkigai Law
  • About Us
    • About
    • Our Team
    • FinTales
    • Tech Ticker
  • Practice Areas
  • Blog
  • News & Events
    • Ikigai Law in the news
    • Ikigai Law at events
    • Ikigailaw on the social media
  • Careers

Niti Aayog’s discussion paper on digital banks

    Home Fintech Niti Aayog’s discussion paper on digital banks
    NextPrevious

    Niti Aayog’s discussion paper on digital banks

    By Ikigai Law | Fintech | 0 comment | 5 May, 2022 | 0

    This post explores Niti Aayog’s proposal to create a licensing framework for fully digital banks. It examines the impact of this proposal on neo-banks and explains the roadmap for implementation.

    If I had a rupee for every time I heard the word ‘neobank’, I’d deposit all those rupees in a neobank. Despite being a fintech buzzword, neobanks have not made remarkable strides in India. As they operate in a regulatory vacuum. So, in November 2021, Niti Aayog stepped-up as the bellwether for neobank regulations. And published a discussion paper on full-stack digital banks. Niti Aayog’s proposed regulatory model would enable neobanks to operate as the utility layer as well as the engagement layer of financial services.  

    The discussion paper explains the value proposition of neobanks, and lays down an implementation plan to put the bank in ‘neobank’. Here is all you need to know about the proposal and our take on it. 

    An idea whose time has come 

    An end-to-end digital bank model has not been green lit under Indian law. Which means neo-banks must partner with banks or other licensed entities to launch their platforms. As a result, most neo-banks end up acting as front-end technology layers. Traditional banks act as utility layer, and perform the core functions. So, neo-banks are not equipped with regulatory freedom to create ground-up innovative products. The Niti Aayog report highlights that neobanks have limited revenue potential (under current regulatory framework). They either earn fee-based revenue as partners or a fraction of interchange for processing payments. So, neobanks rely on equity capital to meet their operational costs, because unlike banks, they can’t accept deposits. Low entry barriers (in absence of regulations) also aid entry of rogue players in the market.   

    As for financial inclusion, the report mentions that it is questionable how far traditional banks have been able to enable financial inclusion and bank the underbanked. India’s small businesses continue to suffer from the same old malaise – lack of access to credit. As small businesses opt for informal credit, traditional banks find it difficult to assess their creditworthiness. And in cases where underwriting is simpler, the financial rewards (for banks) are not worth the risk.  

    Neobanks, armed with technological tools, offer high-cost efficiency. Operational costs for traditional players may be 10-20 times higher than that of neobanks. Neobanks with lower customer acquisition cost and cost-to-serve have the headroom to offer cheaper financial services at a faster pace. And they can be the be-all end-all for financial inclusion. 

    Blueprint for licensing 

    Niti Aayog’s paper proposes implementation of full stack digital banks in three stages – (i) introduction  of a digital business bank license with restrictions on asset sizes and deposits; (ii) enlistment and assessment of the licensee under the RBI’s regulatory sandbox; and (iii) grant of a full-stack digital business bank license based on the performance of the licensee in the sandbox. 

    Niti Aayog’s paper also proposes that RBI must allow digital banks to provide complementary non-financial services. Like payroll management, account receivables management and tax management. This can create seamless user experience and offer digital banks additional monetisation avenues. For this, the RBI will need to increase the remit of banking companies under the banking regulation law.     

    A utopian dream or an impending reality 

    A full stack digital bank in the hands of new age disruptors sounds utopian. A proof of concept is available in UPI, which enabled mass adoption of instant retail payments through participation of start-ups and tech giants. With their deep pockets to market and technical expertise, full stack digital banks could make banking as ubiquitous as UPI. Niti Aayog’s proposal is tacit approval of the necessity of digital first neobanks.  

    (This post has been authored by the fintech team at Ikigai Law.)

    Fintech, Neobanking, NITI Aayog

    Ikigai Law

    More posts by Ikigai Law

    Related Post

    • The Diary of a Fintech Entrepreneur

      By Ikigai Law | 0 comment

      A sneak peek at a fintech founder’s diary as she navigates business opportunities and regulatory curveballs.   A Tale of Two Cities begins with the now immortal lines: it was the best of times, it was theRead more

    • A Letter to UPI

      By Ikigai Law | 0 comment

      A letter from a disgruntled Rs.100 note reminding UPI that cash is still king. “This is an outstanding accomplishment. It indicates the collective resolve of the people of India to embrace new technologies and makeRead more

    • RBI Restricts Access to Card Transaction Data

      By Ikigai Law | 0 comment

      An analysis of RBI’s card directions that restrict fintech’s access to card transaction data and their interplay with RBI’s outsourcing guidelines.  In April 2022, RBI notified the directions on Credit and Debit Cards. In these directions,Read more

    • The Payments Monetization Trilemma

      By Ikigai Law | 0 comment

      A Bandersnatch-inspired story that follows a fintech entrepreneur as she tries to monetize a payments business in India.  In the film Bandersnatch, viewers make decisions for the main character – the young game programmer Stefan Butler. ItRead more

    • FinTales 2022 Round-Up

      By Ikigai Law | 0 comment

      The best stories of 2022 from our monthly fintech newsletter, FinTales. February 2022: The Hassleocracy of Crypto-taxes “Cryptos have no underlying assets, not even a tulip.” –Shaktikanta Das Ouch. That’s the RBI Governor, not mincingRead more

    NextPrevious

    Tags

    #DataProtection #Fintales bitcoin Blockchain Budget Consent Consultation Consultation Paper cryptocurrency data Data Controllers data governance Data localisation Data Protection Data Subjects digital economy Digital India Drones E-Commerce Facebook Fintech Government Government of India healthtech Ikigai Law India Indian government Innovation MeITY Notice Payments Personal Data policy Privacy RBI Recommendation Regulation Srikrishna Committee Stakeholders Startups Surveillance Technology Tech Policy TechTicker TRAI

    Connect with Ikigai Law

    Copyright 2018 Ikigai Law | All Rights Reserved             

    Information

    • Practice Areas
    • Blog
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy

    Contact us

    Office
    T-7/402, Commonwealth Games Village Apartment,
    New Delhi, Delhi 110092 India.

    Email Address

    contact@ikigailaw.com

    • About Us
      • About
      • Our Team
      • FinTales
      • Tech Ticker
    • Practice Areas
    • Blog
    • News & Events
      • Ikigai Law in the news
      • Ikigai Law at events
      • Ikigailaw on the social media
    • Careers
    Ikigai Law