Ikigai LawIkigai LawIkigai LawIkigai Law
  • About Us
    • About
    • Our Team
    • FinTales
    • Tech Ticker
  • Practice Areas
  • Blog
  • News & Events
    • Ikigai Law in the news
    • Ikigai Law at events
    • Ikigailaw on the social media
  • Careers

The Tax on Angels

    Home Digital Economy The Tax on Angels
    NextPrevious

    The Tax on Angels

    By Ikigai Law | Digital Economy | 0 comment | 12 August, 2019 | 4

    In the 2G scam, prosecutors allege that the mode in which a former telecom minister received bribes, was by having the briber purchase shares in a company owned by the said minister’s brother at an exaggerated price that had little to nothing to do with the actual valuation of the company[1].

    It was to prevent situations such as these, that the tax under section 56 (2)(viib)[2] – now popularly referred to as ‘angel tax’ – was introduced by erstwhile finance minister Pranab Mukherjee under the Union Budget of 2012-13. It popularly referred to as ‘angle tax’ as it impacted the angel investments of start-up companies the most.

    The provision contemplates that whenever any company issues shares to an Indian investor at a price higher than the fair market value of such shares, the amount of excess money received by the company, should be treated as income in the hands of the company, and be taxed accordingly.

    Though set in motion with the best of intentions, angel tax provisions ended up targeting and burdening the wrong set of people for the wrong reason. Most investors value a start-up basis its potential for future revenues as opposed to its current book value. Which means that start-ups, more often than not, fall on the wrong side of the angel tax provision, as the shares are issued to the Investor at a premium to the current valuation of the start-up. Correspondingly, the start-up might take a substantial tax hit for every round of investment, and in particular angel investments, which often provide the much-needed flow of money to the fledgling start-ups before funding from venture capital groups may be availed.

     

    To make matters worse if a start-up is found guilty of evading the angel tax provision, it may face a penalty equal to 300% of the original tax assessment.

     

    To rein in the negative effect, the government has exempted qualifying start-ups from the applicability of the angel tax provisions[3]. These qualifying start-ups should satisfy the following criteria:

    Going one step further, the Finance Minister during her budget speech, announced that, “To resolve the so-called ‘Angel Tax’ issue, startups and their investors who file requisite declarations and provide information in their returns will not be subjected to any kind of scrutiny in respect of valuations of share premiums. The issue of establishing the identity of the investor and source of his funds will be resolved by putting in place a mechanism of e-verification. With this, funds raised by startups will not require any kind of scrutiny from the Income Tax Department.”

    It is yet to be seen whether these well intentioned measures will bear fruits for the start-up industry. Early figures are promising and the government states that out of the 381 start-ups who have applied for the benefit of the exemption so far 342 have already been granted the benefit[4]. The exemption though fails to provide any relief to start-ups against whom prosecution has already been initiated under the angel tax provision.

     

    [This post has been authored by Tanya Sadana, Senior Associate, Ikigai Law with inputs from Nimisha S. Dutta, Counsel, Ikigai Law]

    [1] https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/2g-court-to-pass-order-on-dayanidhi-maran-and-kalanithi-maran-pleas-on-jurisdiction/articleshow/53889320.cms

    [2] §56(2)(viib), Income Tax Act, 1961

    [3] Available at https://www.incometaxindia.gov.in/communications/notification/notification_13_2019.pdf

    [4] https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/small-biz/startups/newsbuzz/342-startups-get-angel-tax-exemption-since-february/articleshow/69024367.cms?from=mdr

    Angel Tax, Ikigai Law, impact on angel investment, India, law simplified, start-up ecosystem, tax

    Ikigai Law

    More posts by Ikigai Law

    Related Post

    • Our comments on ISRO’s Space Remote Sensing Policy and Norms, Guidelines and Procedures 2020

      By Ikigai Law | 0 comment

      The Department of Space of the Indian government released a draft ‘Space Remote Sensing Policy 2020’ and ‘Norms, Guidelines and Procedures to implement the Space RS Policy 2020’ in November 2020. This blogpost discusses ourRead more

    • Tax on ESOPs Deferred for Start-ups

      By Ikigai Law | 0 comment

      Tax implications on exercise of ESOPs often render them less than useful. Budget 2020 changes this by deferring the tax liability. When employees exercised their employee stock options (ESOPs) and collected shares, they were, untilRead more

    • BVLOS drone operations: Some suggestions

      By Ikigai Law | 0 comment

      I. Introduction In this post, we look at the global regulatory framework with respect to Beyond Visual Line of Sight (“BVLOS”) Operations,[1] with a specific focus at the United States and Europe. We begin byRead more

    • ‘Digital Technology Policy for India’s USD 5 Trillion Economy’ report launched

      By Ikigai Law | 0 comment

      We are delighted to announce the launch of the ‘Digital Technology Policy for India’s USD 5 Trillion Economy’, an IAMAI report authored by Ikigai Law (available here). The report was launched in New Delhi onRead more

    • Angel tax in India: A timeline

      By Ikigai Law | 0 comment

      Angel tax has been a cause of concern  in the startup and angel investor community since 2012. It is a tax levied on investments in startups by treating the investment, or a part of theRead more

    Leave a Comment

    Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    NextPrevious

    Tags

    #DataProtection #Fintales bitcoin Blockchain Budget Consent Consultation Consultation Paper cryptocurrency data Data Controllers data governance Data localisation Data Protection Data Subjects digital economy Digital India Drones E-Commerce Facebook Fintech Government Government of India healthtech Ikigai Law India Indian government Innovation MeITY Notice Payments Personal Data policy Privacy RBI Recommendation Regulation Srikrishna Committee Stakeholders Startups Surveillance Technology Tech Policy TechTicker TRAI

    Connect with Ikigai Law

    Copyright 2018 Ikigai Law | All Rights Reserved             

    Information

    • Practice Areas
    • Blog
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy

    Contact us

    Office
    T-7/402, Commonwealth Games Village Apartment,
    New Delhi, Delhi 110092 India.

    Email Address

    contact@ikigailaw.com

    • About Us
      • About
      • Our Team
      • FinTales
      • Tech Ticker
    • Practice Areas
    • Blog
    • News & Events
      • Ikigai Law in the news
      • Ikigai Law at events
      • Ikigailaw on the social media
    • Careers
    Ikigai Law